2008 - Philadelphia Soul 59, San Jose SaberCats 56
2007 - San Jose SaberCats 55, Columbus Destroyers 33
2006 - Chicago Rush 69, Orlando Predators 61
2005 - Colorado Crush 51, Georgia Force 48
2004 - San Jose SaberCats 69, Arizona Rattlers 62
2003 - Tampa Bay Storm 43, Arizona Rattlers 29
2002 - San Jose SaberCats 52, Arizona Rattlers 14
2001 - Grand Rapids Rampage 64, Nashville Kats 42
2000 - Orlando Predators 41, Nashville Kats 38
1999 - Albany Firebirds 59, Orlando Predators 48
1998 - Orlando Predators 62, Tampa Bay Storm 31
1997 - Arizona Rattlers 55, Iowa Barnstormers 33
1996 - Tampa Bay Storm 42, Iowa Barnstormers 38
1995 - Tampa Bay Storm 48, Orlando Predators 35
1994 - Arizona Rattlers 36, Orlando Predators 31
1993 - Tampa Bay Storm 51, Detroit Drive 31
1992 - Detroit Drive 56, Orlando Predators 38
1991 - Tampa Bay Storm 48, Detroit Drive 42
1990 - Detroit Drive 51, Dallas Texans 27
1989 - Detroit Drive 39, Pittsburgh Gladiators 26
1988 - Detroit Drive 24, Chicago Bruisers 13
1987 - Denver Dynamite 45, Pittsburgh Gladiators 16