User ID
Password
  Forgot User ID
or Register Today!
VegasInsider.com
VI Mobile Scores and Betting OddsVI Mobile Scores and Betting Odds Be Social
Home
NFL
NBA
NHL
MLB
NCAA FB
NCAA BK
Golf
Auto
Horses
Soccer
Boxing/MMA
More
Betting Tools

 
UNC athlete literacy findings flawed

Research data from a University of North Carolina reading specialist doesn't support claims of low athlete literacy levels at the school, according to reports released Friday from three outside experts.

Advertisement
The university hired Georgia State, Minnesota and Virginia professors to review Mary Willingham's findings. Willingham told CNN in January that her research of 183 football or basketball players from 2004-12 found 60 percent reading at fourth- to eighth-grade levels and roughly 10 percent below a third-grade level.

One expert estimated about 7 percent of athletes from Willingham's research read at fourth- to eighth-grade levels in his report. The school says the data included scores for 176 athletes, including baseball and volleyball players, and was based on testing to screen for learning disabilities or other problems.

The school said it had about 1,800 athletes attend the school during the 8-year period.

UNC had called Willingham's findings flawed after its own internal review of her data, which she provided to Provost James W. Dean Jr., on Jan. 13. She has stood by her findings and said in a statement Friday that she needed time to review the reports before ''a full response.''

''For now I will just say that I am disappointed that the university neglected to take even the most basic steps to ensure the integrity, impartiality and fairness of its supposedly `independent' review of my data,'' Willingham said. ''The fact that they engaged in this exercise without ever seeking input from me or my research partner, and without the raw scores, or an examination of the full battery of tests ... speaks volumes about the true motivations behind today's press release.

''UNC personnel with the knowledge and expertise to verify my claims continue to remain and/or are being forced to remain silent.''

The three experts hired by the school in February were: Nathan R. Kuncel, a professor of industrial-organizational psychology at Minnesota; Lee Branum-Martin, an associate psychology professor at Georgia State and a co-investigator at the school's Center for the Study of Adult Literacy; and Dennis Kramer, an assistant professor of higher education at Virginia.

Kramer, the program adviser for Virginia's intercollegiate athletics master's concentration, was the expert who estimated about 7 percent of athletes from Willingham's research read at fourth- to eighth-grade levels. He cautioned the data is only ''a snapshot.''

''My review looked at just the data I was provided and based all the claims I made from the data that was provided,'' Kramer said. ''Individuals like Mary Willingham, I respect them tremendously for the work they do to support student-athletes.''

UNC spokeswoman Karen Moon said in an email Friday that the school paid them $5,000 each for their work. The school said each worked independently on a review of Willingham's data, which it had said was based largely on the results of standardized scores in a 25-question multiple-choice Scholastic Abilities Test for Adults (SATA) vocabulary test.

According to the executive summary prepared by Dean's office and approved by the outside experts, that SATA vocabulary test ''should not be used to draw conclusions about student reading ability.'' It also states that reading levels ''should not be reported as grade equivalents.''

In January, the school halted Willingham's research until she receives approval from a review board governing human research because it contained information that could identify the subjects.

Willingham's data included names of athletes, the year they entered the school, their sport. It also included SAT scores and GPA information added after the original screening, according to Friday's executive summary. The school said some baseball players were incorrectly listed as men's basketball players.

The review comes during a long-running period of tension in Chapel Hill over academics and athletics, particularly after the 2011 discovery of fraud in an academic department that included lecture classes with significant athlete enrollments that didn't meet and were instead treated as independent studies requiring only a research paper.

Willingham has said they were designed to keep athletes eligible. Former U.S. Justice Department official Kenneth Wainstein is conducting an investigation, the third commissioned by the school, into the causes of the fraud.

---

Follow Aaron Beard on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/aaronbeardap

Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and Associated Press.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written
consent of STATS LLC and Associated Press is strictly prohibited.

  
HEADLINES
Schwab: Big Monday Tip Sheet
Williams: Top 25 Betting Recap
Marshall: Bracketology Update
Villanova, Kansas stay 1-2 in AP Top 25
Gonzaga lands at No. 3, gaining respect
Dozier looking to return for South Carolina
Defense fuels resurgence at Illinois State
Kentucky wary of upset as it meets Vols
MORE HEADLINES
 
Why Buy Picks From VegasInsider.com
NCAA BK College Basketball Handicapper Sports Picks Records
NCAA BK Hot Streaks
12-2 L14 Guarantees, 12-3 L5 Days
9-2 Run, 31-15 G-Plays, +2,135 TY
11-3 Run, 21-7 Picks, 12-3 G-Plays
11-1 G-Plays, 6-1 Y'day, 36-18 L54
8-4 L2 Days, 15-6 L21 Streak
6-3 Totals, 11-6 G-Plays, +2,641 TY
4-1 L5 Picks, 9-2 L11 G-Plays
4-0 L4 Guaranteed Plays
2-0 Saturday, 10-4 L14 Guarantees
4-1 CBK Record Sunday
5-1 L6 Over/Under Plays
4-2 L3 Days, 60% +1,167 TY
NCAA BK Basketball Expert Sports Picks - North Carolina State Wolfpack at Duke Blue Devils
2016 CBK SEASON PICK RECORDS
Money Leaders
Handicapper Money
NeiltheGreek + 2641
Bruce Marshall + 2151
Bill Marzano + 2135
Last 7 Day Leaders
Handicapper Money
Antony Dinero + 1483
Don Anthony + 940
Scott Rickenbach + 778
Percentage Leaders
Handicapper Pct
Michael Black 60 %
Brian Edwards 60 %
Don Anthony 59 %
Guaranteed Leaders
Handicapper Money
Bill Marzano + 1347
Scott Rickenbach + 1005
Brian Edwards + 715
Over-Under Leaders
Handicapper Money
NeiltheGreek + 2111
Antony Dinero + 1276
Bill Marzano + 615
Member Leaders
Handicapper Money
Kyle Hunter + 1634
Bruce Marshall + 1470
NeiltheGreek + 1265
MORE PICK RECORDS
  
corner graphic
With a VI Gold Membership, you can SAVE 10% off a Live Odds subscription, SAVE 20% off Daily Pick packages, and receive access to up to 1,000 Member Plays each month!
VI Gold Membership