VegasInsider.com
VI Mobile Scores and Betting OddsVI Mobile Scores and Betting Odds Be Social
Home
NFL
NBA
NHL
MLB
NCAA FB
NCAA BK
Golf
Auto
Horses
Soccer
Boxing/MMA
More
Betting Tools

 
A-Rod wants video deposition private

NEW YORK (AP) - Alex Rodriguez' lawyers want to keep a lid on potential video of him being questioned in his lawsuit against a New York Yankees team doctor, and a judge indicated Tuesday they might have valid concerns about sensitive medical queries becoming fodder for online sensation.

Advertisement
But a lawyer for the doctor cautioned the court against affording special protections to a celebrity, even though the attorney said he had no intention of releasing such a video, if it eventually exists.

The dispute - an early skirmish in the suspended Yankees slugger's legal fight over treatment of a 2012 hip injury - hints at the heat the case could generate, even though it's separate from the Rodriguez' bigger and now-resolved battle against Major League Baseball.

''The reality is that Mr. Rodriguez is a celebrity,'' so someone could aim to use such a video in ways that would raise privacy concerns, Bronx state Supreme Court Justice Douglas McKeon put it Tuesday. He suggested that that attorneys for both sides agree not to disseminate the possible video to anyone else without the court's input.

There's no pact as yet; another court date is set April 4.

Last month, Rodriguez withdrew two lawsuits against Major League Baseball over its investigation into whether he used banned, performance-enhancing drugs, which he has denied. He agreed to accept a season-long suspension, the longest penalty in baseball history related to performance boosters.

But he is continuing to pursue his medical malpractice case against orthopedic surgeon Dr. Christopher Ahmad and a New York hospital.

Rodriguez' suit says Ahmad didn't tell the third baseman that an October 2012 MRI showed a left hip joint tear. Rodriguez says he therefore kept playing - in the American League playoffs - and worsened the injury, which ultimately required surgery in January 2013.

Ahmad denies the allegations. ''His care of Mr. Rodriguez was always according to appropriate standards of care,'' said his lawyer, Peter T. Crean.

Depositions, or sworn pretrial questioning outside court, are customary in civil cases and can be videotaped. They're often not made public before trial.

New York courts have sometimes nixed video depositions on grounds that they could be tools of humiliation. In 1999, an appeals court ruled that Marla Maples' former publicist couldn't depose her on camera, saying he was mainly seeking ''a unique opportunity to further his harassment and embarrassment of Maples.''

But a judge denied model Fabio's 1995 bid to keep cameras from rolling at his deposition or bar its distribution; the judge said there wasn't evidence to support his worry that his adversaries in the case, a legal fee fight, would sell the tape.

Rodriguez wants to avoid leaks of video of him answering potentially touchy medical questions, said his lawyer, Alan S. Ripka.

He said he couldn't be sure what defense lawyers might ask. It's not clear whether performance enhancing drugs might be raised, although they aren't at issue in the case now.

Regardless, ''just because he's a famous baseball player doesn't mean he's not sensitive about personal medical issues,'' and it wouldn't be fair if his demeanor in discussing them became grist for commentary.

But Ahmad's lawyer said that Rodriguez' concerns were speculative, and that his privacy concerns didn't merit special protections when he was the one who instigated the case and the publicity surrounding it.

''We're at risk of setting a tone here that this case should be handled differently because of (Rodriguez),'' he told the judge, and doing that would be ''placing Dr. Ahmad at a disadvantage.''

Meanwhile, Ahmad and the hospital are seeking to have the case moved to Manhattan, which Rodriguez' camp opposes. That issue also will be up for discussion April 4.

Copyright 2018 by STATS LLC and Associated Press.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written
consent of STATS LLC and Associated Press is strictly prohibited.

  
HEADLINES
News: 2018 SuperBook HR Odds
Bucs make "emotionally challenging" trade
LeBlanc agrees to deal with Yanks
Duffy pleads guilty to DUI in KC suburb
Blue Jays announce plans for netting
Hand deal with Padres includes big bonus
Ozuna excited to join playoff contender
Giants acquire McCutchen from Pirates
Morneau to retire with Twins sendoff
MORE HEADLINES
 
Why Buy Picks From VegasInsider.com
MLB Pro Baseball Handicapper Sports Picks Records
VegasInsider.com Gold Membership
2017 MLB SEASON PICK RECORDS
Money Leaders
Handicapper Money
Gary Bart + 2230
Stephen Nover + 1583
ASA + 1333
Underdog Leaders
Handicapper Money
Chip Chirimbes + 1971
Stephen Nover + 1351
Vince Akins + 1017
Over-Under Leaders
Handicapper Money
NeiltheGreek + 1322
Kyle Hunter + 719
Joe Nelson + 682
Guaranteed Leaders
Handicapper Money
John Fisher + 513
ASA + 290
Kevin Rogers + 159
Favorite Leaders
Handicapper Money
John Fisher + 1356
Scott Rickenbach + 941
Stephen Nover + 724
Member Leaders
Handicapper Money
Stephen Nover + 1720
Dave Cokin + 1514
ASA + 1049
MORE PICK RECORDS
  
corner graphic
With a VI Gold Membership, you can SAVE 20% off Daily Pick packages, SAVE 10% off a Live Odds subscription, and receive access to up to 1,000 Member Plays each month!
VI Gold Membership