User ID
Password
  Forgot User ID
or Register Today!
VegasInsider.com
Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on Twitter Follow Us on Google+ VI Mobile Scores and Betting Odds
Home
NFL
NBA
NHL
MLB
NCAA FB
NCAA BK
Golf
Auto
Horses
Soccer
Boxing/MMA
More
Betting Tools

 
Goodell suggests ditching the PAT kick

Roger Goodell doesn't want to stand pat with the PAT. He's suggesting potential changes in the extra point that, well, might have some legs.

Advertisement
The NFL commissioner says the extra point kick after touchdowns, which had a success rate of nearly 100 percent, is too automatic. Sure is.

And with few teams attempting 2-point conversion plays until desperation hits late in games, the old 1-pointer from 20 yards is the way coaches go. All that does is draw yawns.

So Goodell wonders if the league can add excitement by making some major adjustments to the extra point, suggesting perhaps making a touchdown worth seven points instead of six, with teams having the option to run a play for another point.

But failing on that play would cost them a point.

Gimmicky, for sure. But if Goodell likes the idea ...

A look at how changes to the extra point would affect football:

HOW AND WHO?

Passing any changes to the playing rules in the NFL is, unlike the extra point kick, no snap.

The competition committee meets with the players' union at the NFL combine in February, where any new proposals or ideas are discussed. It's not unusual for the players to have input in potential adjustments, as they did recently on defenseless player penalties.

The powerful committee, chaired by Atlanta Falcons President Rich McKay, meets for about a week in early March and comes up with any proposals, whether from the teams or union or, yes, the big boss.

At the league meetings later in March, the committee presents potential changes for discussion by all 32 owners, who can either vote on them or table them.

McKay said Tuesday: ''We do anticipate the topic being discussed.''

KICKING AROUND?

The idea of toying with the extra point is not entirely new. John Mara, owner of the New York Giants and among the most influential members of the competition committee, says ''it came up for brief discussion in past meetings, but no action was taken.''

It took the NFL years to come around on the 2-point conversion, which can be a pass or run play from the 2-yard line - and under Goodell's apparent preference, could be worth one point if the kick is eliminated. The 2-pointer existed in the old AFL from 1960-69, and college football has had it since 1958.

But it was defeated several times in NFL owners' votes before it passed in 1994 as part of a package of changes to help the offenses.

YEA AND NAY

Coaches will hate any changes, particularly ones that would mean more decisions for them to make. They so rarely go for the 2-pointers until the fourth quarter, and are reluctant to do so then because, well, there's nothing automatic about those attempts. Indeed, less than half (33 of 69) worked in 2013.

''I will say this: Since 2000, I believe, over 99 percent of the extra points are made,'' Falcons coach Mike Smith said. ''It's almost a given that it is going to be made. I'm sure that the competition committee will address it. As a coach you have to play how the rules are.''

Short-yardage backs such as All-Pro fullback Mike Tolbert of Carolina shouldn't mind the elimination of PAT kicks. Nor should running quarterbacks such as Russell Wilson, Colin Kaepernick and Cam Newton, whose improvisational skills would be a huge advantage.

Kickers? They probably will shrug and practice their field goals - which is what they normally do regarding extra points anyway.

WHO STAYS, AND WHY

Rosters would get slight revamping, with teams likely keeping at least one power back active every week and having two on the roster. Often, those guys also play on special teams, so their presence wouldn't throw a lineup out of whack.

PRACTICE WON'T MAKE PERFECT

Teams would work even more on their short-yardage packages, beginning in training camp. They would use their PAT offenses in other situations on the field in games, too.

While going for a fourth-and-2 near midfield is less rare than it once was, it might become all the more common when coaches know the more times they attempt such plays, the more seasoned their players will be when trying for the extra points.

WILL IT HAPPEN?

It's impossible to gauge the owners' thinking, and a three-quarters majority is needed to pass any rules changes.

''I know a lot of times when we're at owner meetings, those things are brought up, and it's great when you're in those meetings because you hear all the different opinions that are brought up with that,'' Jaguars coach Gus Bradley said. ''I'm sure there will be discussions about that. I'm excited about hearing all those.''

Goodell doesn't get a vote.

Then again, it sounds like he already has cast his.

---

AP Sports Writer John Zenor contributed to this story.

---

Online: http://pro32.ap.org/poll and http://twitter.com/AP-NFL

AP NEWS
The Associated Press News Service

Copyright 2016
The Associated Press
All Rights Reserved

  
HEADLINES
Lawrence: Week 3 Preseason Trends
Sportsbook: NFC West Win Totals
Mejia: Dinero Talks: Preseason Week 3
Sportsbook: NFC South Win Totals
Sportsbook: NFC North Win Totals
Nelson: Close Calls - Preseason Week 2
Lawrence: NFC Betting Preview
Lawrence: AFC Betting Preview
Sportsbook: AFC West Win Totals
MORE HEADLINES
 
Why Buy Picks From VegasInsider.com
NFL Pro Football Handicapper Sports Picks Records
NFL Hot Streaks
3-1 G-Plays, 4-1 +315 L5 Picks
2-0 G-Plays, 5-2 Picks TY
9-4 NFL Totals TY
4-1 Last 5 NFL Selections
10-6 Last 16 Plays
2-0 Totals, 3-0 Guarantees TY
4-1 Picks This Year
6-2 L8 Over/Under Plays
3-0 Record L3 Selections
4-2 Last 6 Guarantees
4-1 Last 5 NFL Picks
NFL Pro Football Expert Sports Picks- Dallas Cowboys at Seattle Seahawks
2016 NFL SEASON PICK RECORDS
Money Leaders
Handicapper Money
Gary Bart + 339
Marc Lawrence + 305
Joe Nelson + 290
Last Week's Leaders
Handicapper Money
Chip Chirimbes + 300
Kevin Rogers + 290
Don Anthony + 288
Percentage Leaders
Handicapper Pct
Jimmy Boyd 100 %
Joe Nelson 80 %
Marc Lawrence 71 %
Guaranteed Leaders
Handicapper Money
Scott Pritchard + 300
Don Anthony + 205
Joe Nelson + 190
Over-Under Leaders
Handicapper Money
Antony Dinero + 467
Stephen Nover + 200
Scott Pritchard + 200
Member Leaders
Handicapper Money
Gary Bart + 379
Kevin Rogers + 290
Doc's Sports + 200
MORE PICK RECORDS
  
corner graphic
With a VI Gold Membership, you can SAVE 10% off a Live Odds subscription, SAVE 20% off Daily Pick packages, and receive access to up to 1,000 Member Plays each month!
VI Gold Membership