Jimmy Kimmel Replacement Odds

After Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension, speculation is swirling over who could step in as ABC’s next late-night host. VegasInsider has calculated the replacement odds, highlighting the favorites, long shots, and even a few wild-card names who could take the desk.

Jimmy Kimmel Replacement Odds

Favorites: Jenner and Schneider Lead the Market

Caitlyn Jenner tops the board at +250, making her the favorite to replace Kimmel. Her celebrity name recognition, Republican credentials, and political experience keep her in the conversation, even if her polarizing reputation poses challenges.

Rob Schneider follows closely at +400. With an SNL background, Hollywood ties, and outspoken conservative stance, he checks both the comedy and political boxes for a Kimmel replacement.

Tim Allen rounds out the top tier at +600, with a long track record of network TV success. His conservative leanings are well known, but his more measured tone makes him one of the safer bets.

Mid-Tier Contenders

Greg Gutfeld (+700) already dominates the late-night space on Fox, and ABC would dream of pulling his ratings power to broadcast TV. However, contractual hurdles make it a tough sell. Dennis Miller (+1000) offers decades of satirical credibility but may struggle to capture younger audiences in 2025.

Meanwhile, Tomi Lahren (+1200) and Steven Crowder (+1500) represent younger, social-media-savvy options. Both could bring in a digital-first audience, but their polarizing personas may be too hot for ABC to handle.

Long Shots and Wild Cards

The back of the board features bigger gambles:

• Kid Rock (+1900) brings star power but is more of a provocateur than a host.
• Candace Owens (+2000) has charisma but is highly divisive.
• Joe Rogan (+2500) is the internet’s biggest talker, though he’s unlikely to give up his podcast empire.
• James Woods (+3500) offers sharp wit but could be too combative for mainstream audiences.

And then there are the true outsiders: Barron Trump (+5000), floated as a Gen Z-friendly pick, and even Donald Trump himself (+10000) — a nod to his TV pedigree on The Apprentice.

⚠️ Disclaimer: These odds are fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. They are designed to inform and amuse readers, not as real betting markets.

However, you can use the Kalshi Referral Code and check out the Jimmy Kimmel prediction markets available on the platform.

Whilst you can’t bet on the next Jimmy Kimmel replacement, you can make smarter picks elsewhere. If you’re gearing up for NFL or College Football, you should definitely check out this bet365 Bonus Code!

Prefer blackjack and slots over football? Then this Golden Nugget Promo Code might be more your style.